We redistributed the 2019-20 RO late payment fund on 04 December 2020. We paid a total of £72,879,688 to suppliers who presented Renewables Obligation Certificates (ROCs) this year. Suppliers received £5.02 per ROC presented after the redistribution of the buy-out fund. From the redistribution of the late payment fund, they have received an extra £0.63 per ROC. This means that the final recycle value for 2019-20 is £5.65.
Details of the late payments we received from suppliers (including interest) and the amounts we redistributed for each RO scheme are in Table 1 below:
Late payments made by suppliers
Late payments redistributed
England & Wales
We redistributed late payments to the suppliers on the same basis as the buy-out fund, i.e. in line with the proportion of the total ROCs they presented across the three schemes. Therefore, each supplier received the same proportion of the late payment fund as they did from the redistribution of the buy-out fund.
As with the buy-out fund, the amounts we redistributed included interest earned on the funds while in our accounts, and are rounded down to the nearest pound.
Suppliers have until 1 September to present ROCs to us or make buy-out payments to meet their obligations. Suppliers who have not met their obligations in full by this date must make late payments by 31 October. Late payments incur a daily interest penalty, at an annualised rate of 5% + Bank of England base rate (so 5.1% this year). This is specified in RO legislation.
Thirty-three supplier groups across 54 obligations failed to meet their obligation by the deadline of 1 September, as outlined in Table 2:
|Supplier||Obligation outstanding (England & Wales)||Obligation outstanding (Scotland)||Obligation outstanding (Northern Ireland)|
|BES Commercial Electricity Limited||£9,142,445.16||£933,600.42||0|
|Breeze Energy Supply Limited||£1,202,963.58||£12,341.34||0|
|Bristol Energy Technology & Services (Supply) Limited||£8,226,698.22||£396,581.40||0|
|Co-Operative Energy Limited||£4,927,804.38||£432,142.02||0|
|Delta Gas and Power Limited||£170,000.00||0||0|
|Effortless Energy Limited||£735,895.08||£37,024.02||0|
|EPG Energy Limited||£832,577.04||£21,755.88||0|
|Euston Energy Limited||£48,145.86||0||0|
|Eversmart Energy Ltd||£1,051,843.14||£56,048.22||0|
|Foxglove Energy Supply Limited||£3,426,112.16||0||0|
|Flow Energy Limited||£2,405,244.24||£240,778.08||0|
|Gulf (Gas & Power) Ltd||£1,041,404.22||£100,681.92||0|
|Home Energy Limited||£2,975.58||£97.56||0|
|MA Energy Limited||£1,679,810.12||0||0|
|Maxen Power Supply Limited||£20,000.00||0||0|
|Nabuh Energy Limited||£2,368,122.66||£315,509.04||0|
|PFP Energy Supplies Limited||£1,418,473.62||£831,650.22||0|
|Pure Planet Energy Limited||£10,345,262.40||0||0|
|Robin Hood Energy Limited||£11,611,347.30||£446,532.12||0|
|Rutherford Energy Supply Limited||£291,899.52||£27,414.36||0|
|Npower Direct Limited||£270,046.08||0||0|
|Simplicity Energy Limited||£15,731.89||0||0|
|Simply Your Energy||£54,292.14||0||0|
|Snowdrop Energy Supply Limited||£146.34||0||0|
|Solarplicity Energy Limited||£1,220,670.72||£98,633.16||0|
|Symbio Energy Limited||£1,200,000.00||0||0|
|Together Energy Supply Limited||£5,643,406.98||£723,114.72||0|
|Tonik Energy Limited||£8,100,943.38||£550,872.54||0|
|Toto Energy Limited||£3,626,256.42||£227,363.58||0|
|Utilita Energy Limited||£17,000,000.00||0||0|
Of the 33 supplier groups across 54 obligations who failed to discharge their obligation by the deadline of 1 September, 30 obligations were fully discharged by the late payment deadline of 31 October. The remaining 24 obligations were not met in full:
|Supplier||Obligation||Amount owed (exc. interest) as of 31 Oct|
|Breeze Energy Supply Limited||RO||£1,202,963.58|
|Effortless Energy Limited||RO||£735,895.08|
|Electraphase Energy Limited||RO||£1,999.98|
|Eversmart Energy Ltd||RO||£1,051,843.14|
|Gnergy Energy Ltd||RO||£632,969.28|
|Nabuh Energy Limited||RO||£2,368,122.66|
|Robin Hood Energy Limited||RO||£11,611,347.30|
|Rutherford Energy Limited||RO||£291,899.52|
|Snowdrop Energy Supply Limited||RO||£146.34|
|Solarplicity Energy Limited||RO||£1,220,670.72|
|Symbio Energy Limited||RO||£506,308.40|
|Tonik Energy Limited||RO||£8,100,943.38|
|TOTO Energy Ltd||RO||£3,626,256.42|
The total shortfall is determined by reference to article 72 of the Renewables Obligation Order 2015 and article 48 of the Renewables Obligation (Scotland) Order 2009.
The total shortfall amount across all RO schemes is £33,135,933.32 (excluding interest). This is distributed across the schemes, as follows:
As a relevant shortfall has been reached, mutualisation has been triggered for both RO and ROS. In line with the RO Orders, suppliers who discharged part or all of their obligation will be contacted to make quarterly payments to make up the shortfall, in proportion to their obligation. Further information on mutualisation can be found within chapter 7 of our Renewables Obligation: Guidance for Suppliers.
Of the suppliers who failed to comply by the 31 October late payment deadline, ten are either in administration or have had their licence revoked.
On 28 October 2020 Ofgem issued a final order to Nabuh Energy Limited, Robin Hood Energy Limited and Symbio Energy Limited to compel the supplier to make the outstanding payment plus interest by 31 October 2020. Symbio Energy Limited made payment shortly after the late payment deadline, as such on 13 November 2020 Ofgem published its notice of proposal to revoke the Final Order imposed on Symbio. Payments received after the late payment deadline will be redistributed at a later date.
RO legislation does not provide for payments received after the late payment deadline. As such, the amount to be mutualised is calculated by reference to the total shortfall in the late payment fund as of 31 October and the mutualisation sum is not recalculated to account for payments received after the late payment deadline. We are unable to pursue Enforcement action against Breeze Energy Supply Limited, Effortless Energy Limited, Electraphase Energy Limited, Eversmart Energy Limited, Gnergy Energy Limited, Rutherford Energy Limited, Snowdrop Energy Supply Limited, Solarplicity Energy Limited, Tonik Energy Limited and Toto Energy Limited, as these suppliers ceased trading before obligations became due. We will seek to recover outstanding payments through the organisations’ Administrators where appropriate.
Through our work on these issues, Ofgem seeks to secure the best outcomes for consumers and the wider energy market.