Supplier Games: How to Spot, Stop, and Win Against Hidden Tactics

Suppliers don’t just sell you energy. They sell confusion. Their business model is simple: keep you overwhelmed, underinformed, and reactive. That’s how they defend their margin. If you think procurement is a level playing field – you’ve already lost.

This guide exposes the games suppliers play, why buyers keep falling for them, and how you stop losing money without even noticing.

The Supplier Playbook

Suppliers rely on tactics designed to create pressure, limit visibility, and erode your decision-making. These aren’t accidents – they’re engineered to tilt the game in their favour.

  • The Deadline Trap: Calls at 4:45pm claiming “rates expire tonight.” Urgency replaces analysis. You sign without leverage.
  • The Opaque Bundle: Folding hidden fees and broker margins into complex tariff structures. You can’t compare. They win.
  • The False Benchmark: Quoting a single “market average” designed to make their offer look competitive. It’s cherry-picked noise.
  • The Fragmentation Play: Splitting portfolios into multiple contracts to prevent consolidated buying power.
  • The Renewal Drift: “Don’t worry, we’ll roll you over.” Translation: locked into uncompetitive rates while they bank margin.

Every one of these tactics is designed to exploit the overwhelmed buyer. If you’re reacting – you’re losing.

Why Smart Companies Still Fall for Supplier Games

Procurement leaders aren’t naive. They’re overloaded. And overload is the supplier’s best weapon. Here’s why even experienced teams fall:

  • Time Pressure: With dozens of sites and constant admin, leaders don’t have bandwidth for deep analysis.
  • Information Asymmetry: Suppliers control the data – volumes, tariffs, forecasts. You’re always playing catch-up.
  • Board Noise: CFOs demand answers on costs now. That pressure drives reactive sign-offs.
  • Market Complexity: Energy markets move daily. Without context, every price looks urgent.

Suppliers know this. Their sales teams are trained to exploit it. Falling for the game isn’t stupidity – it’s structural disadvantage.

The Hidden Cost of Playing by Their Rules

Every time you play the supplier’s game, you bleed money invisibly. The real cost isn’t cents per kilowatt-hour – it’s EBITDA erosion:

  • A rushed renewal costs 3–5% more. On a $750k portfolio, that’s $25k margin gone.
  • Fragmented contracts strip away leverage. Your $1M spend looks like five $200k deals – worth less negotiating power.
  • Opaque billing hides true spend. Finance wastes hours reconciling invoices that never add up.
  • Renewal drift locks you into “default” rates that can sit 10–15% above competitive benchmarks.

Individually, these leaks look small. Together, they are a systemic drain. That’s why boards never see the energy line under control.

How to Counter Supplier Games

Suppliers win when you react. You win when you flip the power dynamic. Here’s how procurement leaders neutralise the games:

  • Own the Data: Centralise contracts, volumes, and renewals across every site. When you see everything, they can’t exploit gaps.
  • Set the Timeline: Don’t wait for supplier calls. Run structured tenders on your schedule, not theirs.
  • Force Transparency: Demand unbundled pricing and explicit broker fees. If they refuse, walk.
  • Consolidate Leverage: Aggregate spend to negotiate from strength. Fragmentation is their tool, not yours.
  • Use Market Intelligence: Don’t buy on today’s “special.” Buy on market trends, forward curves, and risk appetite.

The rule is simple: suppliers are vendors, not advisors. Your procurement discipline – not their pitch – sets the outcome.

Shifting the Conversation to the Boardroom

The board doesn’t care about “competitive tariffs.” They care about margin protection. Procurement wins credibility when it reframes energy decisions as risk management:

  • Show cost leakage as EBITDA impact, not just $/MWh.
  • Report procurement discipline as risk reduction, not admin.
  • Demonstrate control with forward cover strategies – not supplier offers.

When you frame supplier games as threats to margin, the board pays attention. That’s when procurement moves from firefighting to strategy.

Challenging Procurement Myths

Procurement leaders who keep losing to supplier games usually believe myths that protect suppliers:

  • “Suppliers are partners.” Wrong. They’re counterparties with opposing incentives.
  • “It’s just energy, small savings don’t matter.” Wrong. Energy is one of the few controllable costs that directly hits EBITDA.
  • “We can’t influence market prices.” Wrong. You can’t control the market, but you can control when and how you buy.

Kill the myths. Kill the games.

Expose the Supplier Games Before They Cost You More

Every day you let suppliers control the game, you bleed margin. The fix isn’t another rushed renewal – it’s procurement discipline, powered by independent intelligence. The choice is simple: keep reacting, or start dictating terms.

Request a Supplier Exposure Audit
Scroll to Top